I didn't like this eyeliner. And I'm a big eyeliner girl. This takes forever to dry and just doesn't last.

Love all their products! By far my favorite eyeliner!

I like this especially for its price. On my eyes it stays put , it does apply well it is more of a glossy finish not matte . I don't think it is water proof that being said I won't recommed this for anyone who has watery eyes. I would recommend for everyday use

To runny did not last

Great product really worth the dollar you pay for it and it last for long while.

For the price it is a good liquid liner. Does have a good rich black color, but it tends to take long time to dry and requires more coats to cover the smears and lines left by the brush. All in all it's an okay product, good in a pinch.

I really love this eyeliner! It dries fast and last all day! I love that this does not smudge, and with the fine tip it makes really defined lines and is easy to use.

I purchased this E.l.f liquid eyeliner, and it was the first time I ever attempted to use liquid eyeliner so it is hard for me to compare to other products. However, it was easier then I expected and I liked that it came off very easily. I usually use cream eyeliner or pencil and usually have a hard time getting it off before going to bed. But this made my make-up removal process so much easier and faster I know that I will continue to use this product.

I purchased this due to its price, I am a huge liquid eyeliner user. It seems to need many layers to be able to look good. One layer and you can see your eyelid under it. It also kind of clumps....? When you blink it kind of just cracks. I still use it no matter though. I try to make it work with black eye shadow to just help keep it looking black.

Well who doesn't love good quality cheap products? Rich black color, only con for me is a bit runny and takes a little while to dry.

Just about everything I want in an eyeliner. The consistency is great, the color is bold, and the applicator is very easy to use even with delicate designs. My only issue is it has little stay-power (I know it isn't waterproof and don't expect it be), I end up having to redo parts of my eyeliner during a long/hot day.

Its an okay eyeliner. Its not the blackest, and staying power isn't as good as others. I love elf, but this liner left a lot to be desired.

Not the island our product that I would choose to use?

It was ok. A bit runny and I had to reapply.

great product, really worth the dollar you pay for it, and it last for a long while.