I have a hard time with liquid liner, didn't love it

I'm usually a big fan of elf products but this product was a fail for me, the brush forked so it was impossible to get an even line, it takes forever to dry and the formulation is really runny. it smudges and ends up everywhere due to its drying speed.

While I love e.l.f products this not so much. If you don't use primer it will come off really quickly. But when I do prime my eyelid then it does last longer. And for the $1 price you can't beat it!

This eyeliner is amazing!!! My line comes out really clean and it doesn't smudge.

I didn't have good luck with this product. It went on poorly. I tried it twice then threw it away.

I use elf products frequently and was extremly surprised to see how afforable their liquid eyeliner was in comparison to other brands. I don't use make often but when I do I love to use this product over some pencil eyeliner for a long lasting effect. On its own its still a great product to use. I would recommend for anyone wanting to look good on a budget.

Great value for the price. I love elf products. I am extremely picky about my eye liner. This one was not bad at all. Would purchase again.

I don't like the elf liner because it hurts when it gets in the eye. plus it runs in the eye when you put it on.

Being that this is an elf product that usually costs around $1, I believe that it is a great product. You get what you pay for and so much more. This product on my skin lasts the entire day. It is very black and easy to work with.

One of my least favorite elf products. Smells strange, and goes on very streaky.

You really get what you pay for. With this it seemed to peel off after half the day. If it did not peel it got dry and flaked. I dont use this at all anymore.

Stays on all day. The applicator is very stiff, the liquid is very black. it is just an exceptional product for the one dollar spent.

I'm not a big fan of this eyeliner, took too long to dry and had to keep applying throughout the day.

Elf is usually my go to because its cheep and most things work well but this one was runny even after i put powder under it for it to stick to and then once it did dry it would just flake off, I definitely won't be repurchasing this product

I didn't really care too much for this product. It doesn't dry fast and is very runny. If you want something cheap, then maybe this might be for you, but I would put it in the fridge maybe first, see if then it won't be so runny and might stay better :)