im not to crazy about this product. tthe brush of it makes it a bit difficult to apply it feels and looks like a cheap brush but for $3 how can you really go wrong

Okay but there only $1 which is great. You get what you pay for. Clumpy and smelled a little weird. I would reccomend it to a friend though because i find myself running to it when im in desperate need.

i love this eye liner stays on good all day...

great quality for a very cheap price.

I bought this liner in brown. It is nice and dark and easy for me to apply. The only problem I have with it is that it does tend to flake just a little during the day. For the price I think it is a good liquid liner to try.

This product is very easy to apply, however it is not very pigmented. I have this in black, and it goes on very well but looks almost watery at times. I have to keep applying it to get a pure black color. This product works very well for using over a pencil liner to lock it in more!

amazing product I have the color in black, great pigmentation, glides on smoothly, simply inexpensive and amazing

I give this product 3 stars due to one the price, two it lasts long and three its easy to apply. The only thing that drives me nuts about this product, it that when I use make up remover it comes off like stretchy and sometimes ends up in my eyes, so I have to use a q-tip to clean my eye out. Other than that I like the product you can beat it for $1

I love e.l.f. cosmetics. This liquid eyeliner is a great product. My daughter loves it and buys it often.

I have bought a lot of elf products and have loved most of them, sadly not this one. The eyeliner is very hard to apply compared to most liquid eyeliners and it smells bad too! Once you finally get it applyed to your eye, it usually flakes off too quickly to even bother. I would say, save your money and get a little higher quality eye liner!

I dislike the final look of this eyeliner. It is very plastic like and super unnatural looking. It is not too hard to apply if you're used to the thin brushes. I usually wear gel liner or pencil eyeliner so I am used to making thicker lines. May work for you if you like super thin lines. I personally will not buy again. I use the brush for nail art now :P

I don't wear eyeliner all the time and I also prefer a pencil liner as opposed to liquid, but, elf's liquid eyeliner is decent. It's very affordable and is easy to apply.

I swear by E.L.F products. I love their liquid eyeliner. Now i will say the formula of their products that you buy in the store are a lower quality then the products you buy online, they changed their formula so a lot of the products in store are still old formula. But i love the eyeliners, and their eyeshadow...i love it all :)

great stuff, does what its supposed to and it is easy to use, thumbs up!

This is actually a pretty good liquid eyeliner for only $1!! It's one of my favorites