not worth it. so not impressed with this item. the felt tip wasn't sharp, it soaked up more product then ever and when applying it to the eye, it just came as one big hot glop and you might have to use a qtip to clean off the excess liner that was left behind. it wasn't fast drying so those with double eye lids will suffer the smudging effect. and sadly i don't feel that this is even water proof. it just started getting everywhere within 2 hours of wearing it. i was greatly disappointed with this. i am kinda glad that it wasn't expensive. i will not be buying this ever again.

Elf did it again! I love all my elf products but this eyeliner is everything! From the wand being easy to handle and the cute typical packaging. My favorite part is the lack of scent. It glideded on so smooth and was easy to control when I was touching up. For this price I'm stocking up and handing them out as gifts!

too messy The applicator on the E.L.F eyeliner and packaging are good. Unfortunately the formula of the liquid eye liner was runny and made it too messy to use. I wish it were thicker so it was easier to apply. Maybe I got a bad tube. I wouldn't try it again though.

e.l.f liquid eye liner I like this eye liner. It is very pigmented and once it dries down it has staying power. It does however take a while to dry down.

Good and cheap Can be messy but, good for practicing with eyeliner if you are new to liquid.

I love e.l.f. This liner had been the easiest one in liquid form for me to use. It goes on so smooth and lasts the whole night through.

Worth it I love how pigmented it is. For the price it is well worth it!

Good Pretty nice product though It can get kind of messy and it's sometimes quite complicated to use

My go-to Eyeliner As the Founder of a Beauty / Fashion Blog I get to review products on a daily basis. This is one of my favorites and one I use weekly for new Makeup tutorials and blog posts. Totally love this Eyeliner!

Very pigmented at a good price. Easy to apply, doesn't dry up. Love this eyeliner

Not only is this Elf eyeliner affordable, like $1-$2, the eyeliner goes on smooth and silk. This is my go to now. I don't bother with any others!

Stamp away This product takes way to long to dry. If you have the time to let it dry it is a great color and can allow for a very straight line.

Amazing! e.l.f liquid eyeliner is pretty good. My first time trying time was just recently. I spotted it out in our local Dollar Tree. I've always loved e.l.f products and have a collection of them. Pretty good for drawing a winged eye and last for hours. There's not a lot in the bottle though. I would recommend this product.

Great Product for a Great Price One of my Fav eye liners. It really sticks out the only bad thing about it is how it smears very easily hopefully they can come up with waterproof one. great brand for a great price

My favorite! I've been using this liner since i started with makeup. Throughout trying tons of others this one has stayed my #1, I can create my perfect cat eye and it stays on all day!