I like this ingredients list more than the blue bottle. It works just as well, removing all my eyeliner and mascara with a couple gentle swipes of a cotton ball. A little goes a long way so a bottle lasts forever.
honestly I would mot give this product one star because I don't recommend this at all does not work super oil left face dry and chapped I immediately threw it away
Not the best eye-make up remover- have to work hard to get mascara off ( not waterproof) and black eyeliner. You will still find yourself waking up the next morning after you remove makeup and find smudges under your eyes. It is affordable though and if you just wear light eye makeup, perhaps this might be for you.